The UKM StimuGold (UKMSG) Wound Bed | |
Preparation Method: A unique technique in | |
combining Superabsorbent Polymer | |
Polyacrylate Sodium with Collagen–Glycerine | |
ISSN: 2754-8880 Published 00 11 0000 | amorphous base dressing: A case series |
Sim Lin Kiat1* and Farrah-Hani Imran2 | |
1Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Department of Surgery, Universiti Tunku Abdul | |
Rahman, Malaysia | |
2 Plastic, Reconstructive, Burns Wound Care Team, Department of Surgery, Universiti | |
Kebangsaan Malaysia Medical Centre | |
* Correspondence author: Sim Lin Kiat ; kelvsim@gmail.com | |
ORIGINAL | |
Abstract | |
Introduction: A wound is a disruption of the normal structure and function of the skin and its | |
architecture. An acute wound heals predictably, time frame, if any, with few complications but | |
the result is a well-healed wound. A chronic wound is defined as one that is physiologically | |
impaired due to the disruption of the wound healing cycle. Advanced dressings are designed to | |
maintain a moist environment at the site of application, allowing the fluids to remain close to the | |
wound and not spread to the unaffected, healthy skin areas. We developed a unique technique of | |
dressing combining Superabsorbent Polyacrylate Sodium (Gold Dust®) with Collagen-Glycerine | |
base amorphous gel (Stimulen®), A.K.A, UKMSG, in six patients with acute and chronic wounds | |
of various aetiology; referred for recalcitrant, non-healing wound. | |
Case Presentation & Methods: Six patients with acute and chronic wounds of various aetiology | |
were referred for recalcitrant, non-healing wounds. Patients’ data were obtained from medical | |
files and surgical databases. Depending on the size and condition of the wound, the average | |
duration of treatment varies from 1 - 6 weeks. The dressing was done mainly by wound nurses. | |
Dressings were changed from daily to once every three days, based on the type of wounds. It does | |
not need a lot of experience for the application of UKMSG. A short briefing and demonstration on | |
how to apply the dressing would suffice. We did not start adjuvant antibiotics for all our wounds. | |
OPEN ACCESS | Antibiotics were only started for infected wounds and based on cultures & sensitivity. There were |
Edited by | two females and four males. The youngest in the group was 2 years old and the oldest was 72 |
A.Hussain | years old. We had two pressure ulcers, one gangrenous penis, one Surgical Site Infection wound |
Submitted 15 July. 2022 | breakdown post total hysterectomy, one lower abdominal wall necrotizing fasciitis, and a 23% |
Accepted 23 July. 2022 | infected burn wound. All patients’ wounds were initially managed by respective primary teams |
Citation | (except the infected burn wound) with dressings and surgical debridement is done at least once |
Sim Lin Kiat, Farrah-Hani | but a healthy wound bed was still not achieved. |
Imran. The UKM StimuGold | |
(UKMSG) Wound Bed | Results: The UKMSG is part of our Wound Care Team approach to wound management across |
Preparation Method: A | a variety of wounds. Through the case series, we noted that UKMSG is ideal for the treatment |
unique technique in | of recalcitrant, non-healing, moderate to highly exudative wounds. It produces a good result in |
combiPniolnyg mSeurp Peroalybascorrybleatnet | wound bed preparation. It is also easy to apply and removed, comfortable, has fewer peri-wound |
Sodium with | complications, and does not need an expensive secondary dressing. In the future, we aim to |
Collagen–Glycerine | perform an RCT and comparison study to further evaluate the UKMSG method. |
amorphous base dressing: A | |
case series | |
:BJOSS::2022:(3);71-78 |
Keywords : A chronic wound, recalcitrant wound, UKMSG method, Collagen-Glycerine base |
amorphous gel, Superabsorbent Polyacrylate Sodium, dressing, wound debridement. |
Introduction |
A wound is a disruption of the normal structure and function of the skin and its architecture (1). |
An acute wound heals predictably, time frame, if any, with few complications but the result is a |
well-healed wound. A chronic wound is defined as one that is physiologically impaired due to the |
disruption of the wound healing cycle (2). Wound dressings aim to provide an ideal environment |
for its healing. Advanced dressings are designed to maintain a moist environment at the site of |
application, allowing the fluids to remain close to the wound but not spread to the unaffected, |
healthy skin areas (3). |
Advance dressing like a hydrogel is a three-dimensional, hydrophilic polymeric network capable of |
absorbing large amounts of water or biological fluids and it closely simulates natural living tissue |
materials (4). Superabsorbent polymer (SAP) like Polyacrylate Sodium is a special type of hydrogel |
that is ideal for treating recalcitrant, non-healing wounds as it is effective in removing excessive |
exudate-containing inflammatory mediators that ultimately hinder wound healing, not just that, |
it is also an excellent autolytic debridement agent. Collagen, on the other hand, has long been |
known to have a pivotal role in stimulating cell proliferation by acting as a chemo-attractant for |
fibroblasts, hence “jump-starting” the healing processes (5; 6). |
Wound bed preparation (WBP) is the process of removing local barriers to wound healing to |
maximize the potential for successful healing. WBP can be done through debriding nonviable |
tissue, pathogens (biofilm), contaminants, foreign (or other) materials, and drain areas of infection. |
Chronic wounds may require serial surgical wound debridement (WD) to sufficiently prepare the |
wound bed (2). We present a case series of six patients with recalcitrant, non-healing wounds; |
referred to us, The Plastic, Reconstructive, Burns & Wound Care Team, Universiti Kebangsaan |
Malaysia Medical Centre (UKMMC). We developed a unique dressing technique, also known |
as UKM StimuGold (UKMSG), constituting the combination of 2 dressings, ie; Superabsorbent |
Polyacrylate Sodium (Gold Dust®) with Collagen-Glycerine base amorphous gel (Stimulen®) for |
wound management and wound bed preparation (WBP). |
Case Series & Methods |
UKMMC is a Quaternary Referral Centre and Level 1 Trauma Centre situated in Kuala Lumpur, |
Malaysia. Between July 2014 to October 2015, The Plastic, Reconstructive, Burns & Wound |
Care Team, UKMMC developed a unique technique of dressing constituting the combining of |
Superabsorbent Polyacrylate Sodium (Gold Dust®) with Collagen-Glycerine base amorphous gel |
(Stimulen®), in six patients with acute and chronic wounds of various aetiology being referred for |
recalcitrant, non-healing wounds. All wounds were initially managed by the respective primary |
team with dressings and surgical WD but a healthy wound bed was still not achieved. Patients’ |
data were obtained from medical files and surgical databases. There were two females and |
four males. The youngest in the group was 2 years old and the oldest was 72 years old. We |
had two pressure ulcers, one gangrenous penis, one Surgical Site Infection wound breakdown |
post total hysterectomy, one lower abdominal wall necrotizing fasciitis, and a 23% infected burn |
wound. Informed consent was obtained after a thorough history, wound examination, and clinical |
indication for types of dressing before commencing the UKMSG technique. |
The technique involved initial cleansing of the wound with either sterile water, normal saline, or |
superoxide solutions. A small amount of Stimulen® gel is then mixed with the Gold Dust® paste. |
Finally, apply the mixture to the wound bed cavity. The secondary dressing was with gauze and |
gamgee secured with Elastoplast bandages. |
The Gold Dust® comes in sachets, crystalline form. To prepare the Gold Dust® paste, 30mls to |
15mls of sterile water was added into a full pack (30g) or half pack (15g) of Gold Dust® crystal |
71/78 |
respectively and stirred gently to form a paste. Regular wound bed assessment and monitoring | |
were done on all patients via photo documentation noting its granulation tissue, evidence of | |
infection, wound moisture, and wound edges. Several assessment criteria were also evaluated | |
including pain, dour, pruritus, adverse reaction, comfort, and well-being of the patient. Dressing | |
nurses were also interviewed. | |
Case Management And Outcomes | |
Dressings were changed from daily to once every three days, based on the clinician’s judgment | |
and type of wounds. The average duration of treatment is about 1 to 6 weeks. The dressing is | |
done mainly by wound nurses. However, it does not need a lot of experience for the application of | |
UKMSG. A short briefing and demonstration on how to apply the dressing would suffice. We did | |
not start adjuvant antibiotics for all our wounds. Antibiotics were started for infected wounds and | |
based on cultures& sensitivity. In all patients, frequent dressing changes were needed initially but | |
when exudates level decreased and the wound becomes healthier, dressings were changed once | |
every three days. Inspecting the degree of saturation of dressing was easy by simply inspecting | |
the secondary dressing. If it was wet, the dressing will be changed. | |
From the feedback of patients and wound nurses, UKMSG dressing is easy to apply and removed. | |
It is generally comfortable and does not need expensive secondary dressings. There was no | |
adverse reaction in all patients. It had fewer peri-wound complications like itchiness, irritations, | |
and eczema due to its remarkable absorptive ability. It is also a good chemical debridement agent. | |
However, some patients did complain of a slight tingling sensation upon initial application of | |
UKMSG dressing and an unpleasant odour if the dressing was kept for too long. But all these | |
quickly go away once the dressing was changed. Due to its transparency paste form, certain | |
characteristics of bacterial infection like pseudomonas can be easily observed during wound | |
inspection as the entire mixture of dressing would turn green. We found that UKMSG produced | |
an ideal result in WBP, particularly in wounds with moderate to high exudative levels. | |
Case 1: | |
72-years-old man with lower abdominal necrotizing fasciitis, Fournier’s gangrene. 8-surgical WD | |
done. (1a) Started UKMSG for WBP along with serial surgical WD. (1b) A healthy less-exudative | |
granulation tissue. | |
(a) Before UKMSG | (b) After 24-days |
72/78 |
Case 2: | |
64-years-old man, post CABG 2 weeks, excoriation at sacral region progressed into pressure ulcer, | |
grade II. WD done once, refused further WD. (2a) slough with discharge before UKMSG. (2b) | |
Healthy granulation tissue with minimal slough. | |
(a) Before UKMSG | (b) After 20-days |
Case 3: | |
41-years-old lady, post total hysterectomy for symptomatic multiple uterine fibroids. Presented with SSI and wound breakdown. Surgical WD did once. (3a) Highly exudative wound, slough at | |
the base, and foul-smelling discharge before UKMSG. (3b) Healthy moist granulation tissue. | |
(a) Before UKMSG (b) After 7 days | |
73/78 |
Case 4: 2-years-old girl admitted for 23% mixed thickness infected burn wounds at the posterior | |
trunk. 2 surgical WD done. (4a) Resistant exudative wound with discharge. (4b) Healthy epithelized | |
wound. | |
(a) Before UKMSG | (b) After 42-days |
Case 5: | |
30-years old man, Retro-viral (RVD) positive, presented with gangrenous penis due to penis siliconoma. Surgical WD did once. (5a) Sloughy base with discharge. (5b) Healthy granulating | |
tissue. | |
(a) Before UKMSG | (b) After 3 days |
Case 6: | |
43-years-old man with traumatic paraplegia for 20 years and a complex network of clean, static | |
pressure ulcers. Multiple admission for infected pressure ulcer at the sacrum, grade IV. At least | |
3-surgical wound debridement done. (6a) Deep communicating cavity with discharge. (6b) | |
Obliterated communicating-cavity, clean. | |
74/78 |
(a) Before UKMSG (b) After 24-days |
Discussion |
The right choice of dressing for a wound is important for optimum healing, therefore, improving |
the quality of patients’ life (7). Studies have shown that recalcitrant, non-healing wounds contain |
exudate with high levels of inflammatory mediators like matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) (8), |
polymorphonuclear granulocyte-derived elastase (PMN elastase) (9) with high concentrations |
of free radicals (10); which causes a shift in the balance of matrix synthesis leading to tissues |
destruction. Another study attributed the increase of protease activities in exudates as the main |
pathology of non-healing wounds. Therefore, removal of the above will have a major therapeutic |
effect on WBP and granulation tissue formation (8). Eming S at al showed that SAP can inhibit |
MMP activity in vitro and ex vivo (11). SAP also exhibits a high binding capacity for PMN elastase, |
and protease and is able to inhibit free radical formation in vitro (12). It also takes up multiple |
amounts of water (bio-fluids/exudate) of their dry weight which is crucial in chronic wounds and |
wounds with moderate to high exudative levels. Due to its ability to take up and retain proteins as |
well as cell debris and micro-organisms (12), it serves as an excellent autolytic debridement agent. |
Collagen, on the other hand, creates the most physiological interface between the wound surface |
and its environment and it is impermeable to bacteria (13). It is easy to apply, being natural, |
non-immunogenic, nonpyrogenic, hypo-allergenic, and pain-free (14). Collagen also inhibits the |
actions of MMPs and the facilitation of migration of fibroblasts into the wound (5; 15). Glycerine |
is found in many common products such as cosmetics, conditioners, soaps, foods, etc. It is a |
humectant by definition and has the ability to absorb moisture from the wound. We believe that |
by combining Gold Dust® and Stimulen® gel in UKMSG, both dressings augment each other |
therefore producing promising dressing as results in our case series. |
Conclusion |
The UKMSG is part of our Wound Care Team approach to wound management across a variety |
of wounds. We conclude that UKMSG is ideal for the treatment of recalcitrant, non-healing, |
moderate to highly exudative wounds. It produces a good result in WBP. It is also easy to apply |
and removed, comfortable, has fewer peri-wound complications, and does not need an expensive |
secondary dressing. In the future, we aim to perform an RCT and comparison study to further |
evaluate the UKMSG method. |
75/78 |
Disclosure |
Authors have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose. |
Author Contributions |
Dr. Sim Lin Kiat; author/ correspondence Associate Professor Dr. Farah Hani; supervisor All |
authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. |
ORCID ID |
Sim Lin Kiat. https://orcid.org/my-orcid?orcid=0000-0002-2466-8721 |
References |
[1] Atiyeh BS, Ioannovich J, Al-Amm CA, El-Musa KA. Management of acute and chronic |
open wounds: the importance of moist environment in optimal wound healing. Current |
pharmaceutical biotechnology. 2002;3(3):179-95. |
[2] Schultz GS, Sibbald RG, Falanga V, Ayello EA, Dowsett C, Harding K, et al. Wound bed |
preparation: a systematic approach to wound management. Wound repair and regeneration. |
2003;11:S1-S28. |
[3] Patel S, Marshall J, Fitzke FW. Refractive index of the human corneal epithelium and stroma. |
SLACK Incorporated Thorofare, NJ; 1995. |
[4] Peppas NA, Bures P, Leobandung W, Ichikawa H. Hydrogels in pharmaceutical formulations. |
European journal of pharmaceutics and biopharmaceutics. 2000;50(1):27-46. |
[5] Postlethwaite AE, Seyer JM, Kang AH. Chemotactic attraction of human fibroblasts to type |
I, II, and III collagens and collagen-derived peptides. Proceedings of the National Academy |
of Sciences. 1978;75(2):871-5. |
[6] Ohara H, Ichikawa S, Matsumoto H, Akiyama M, Fujimoto N, Kobayashi T, et al. Collagen- |
derived dipeptide, proline-hydroxyproline, stimulates cell proliferation and hyaluronic acid |
synthesis in cultured human dermal fibroblasts. The Journal of dermatology. 2010;37(4):330- |
8. |
[7] Cryer S. Improving the selection of wound dressings in general practice. Nurse Prescribing. |
2015;13(7):336-42. |
[8] Trengove NJ, Stacey MC, Macauley S, Bennett N, Gibson J, Burslem F, et al. Analysis of the |
acute and chronic wound environments: the role of proteases and their inhibitors. Wound |
Repair and Regeneration. 1999;7(6):442-52. |
[9] Barrick B, Campbell EJ, Owen CA. Leukocyte proteinases in wound healing: roles in physio- |
logic and pathologic processes. Wound Repair and Regeneration. 1999;7(6):410-22. |
[10] Rojkind M, Dominguez-Rosales JA, Nieto N, Greenwel P. Role of hydrogen peroxide |
and oxidative stress in healing responses. Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences CMLS. |
2002;59(11):1872-91. |
[11] Eming S, Smola H, Hartmann B, Malchau G, Wegner R, Krieg T, et al. The inhibition of matrix |
metalloproteinase activity in chronic wounds by a polyacrylate superabsorber. Biomaterials. |
2008;29(19):2932-40. |
[12] Wiegand C, Abel M, Ruth P, Hipler U. Superabsorbent polymer-containing wound dress- |
ings have a beneficial effect on wound healing by reducing PMN elastase concentration |
77/78 |
and inhibiting microbial growth. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine. |
2011;22(11):2583-90. |
[13] Park SN, Lee HJ, Lee KH, Suh H. Biological characterization of EDC-crosslinked collagen– |
hyaluronic acid matrix in dermal tissue restoration. Biomaterials. 2003;24(9):1631-41. |
[14] Lazovic G, Colic M, Grubor M, Jovanovic M. The application of collagen sheet in open wound |
healing. Annals of burns and fire disasters. 2005;18(3):151. |
[15] Veves A, Sheehan P, Pham HT, et al. A randomized, controlled trial of Promogran (a colla- |
gen/oxidized regenerated cellulose dressing) vs standard treatment in the management of |
diabetic foot ulcers. Archives of surgery. 2002;137(7):822-7. |
78/78 |